Top 5 Five-Cup Coffee Machines: A Comprehensive Review

15 min read FEB 28, 2024

Are you a coffee enthusiast who shares a home with your partner? Do you both cherish the rich, aromatic allure of a well-brewed cup of coffee but often find yourself brewing more than you can consume? If these scenarios resonate with you, then you might just be the ideal candidate for a 5-cup coffee maker!

This compact yet powerful machine brews the perfect quantity of coffee for two, eliminating the dilemma of wasting surplus coffee or, worse still, forcing yourself to drink it once it's lost its warm charm. If you find it challenging to discard things like me, this coffee maker could be a game-changer.

In the quest to identify the best 5-cup coffee maker available, I have delved deep into the market, critically analyzing various models based on their unique features. Curious to know which coffee machines made it to the top of my list? Keep reading!

AMASTE Drip Coffee Maker

The AMASTE Drip Coffee Maker uniquely appeals to those who appreciate the beloved mid-century modern aesthetic. This stylish appliance is available in a choice of four distinct colors - classic black, vibrant red, the subtly charming apricot orange, and a soothing matcha green. So, you have the freedom to select a color that best compliments your kitchen decor.

In addition to its visually pleasing design, the AMASTE coffee maker is equipped with some fantastic features. One standout trait is its adjustable coffee strength, a versatility feature that's relatively rare in machines within this size and price bracket. You can opt for mild, medium, or strong brew strength depending on your preference.

Another practical feature is the warming plate, which maintains the coffee's heat for 30 minutes post-brewing. The machine will promptly shut down after this half-hour, eliminating the worry of leaving your coffee maker on as you rush out the door in the morning.


  • Offers adjustable coffee strength (mild, medium, or strong)
  • The automatic shut-off after 30 minutes of inactivity adds a safety feature
  • Comes in four different colors to match any kitchen decor
  • The quiet operation ensures a peaceful morning routine


  • The coffee maker's plastic construction may not hold up as long as other more robust models on this list.

KRUPS Simply Brew Compact Filter Drip Coffee Maker

The KRUPS Simply Brew Compact Filter Drip Coffee Maker is an appliance made of steel which makes it stand out in its price range. With one press of a button it can quickly brew a full carafe of coffee in just 5 minutes.

If you're too impatient to wait for the entire pot to brew, the Pause & Serve function allows you to interrupt the brewing process and pour yourself a cup. The warming plate keeps your coffee hot for up to an hour before shutting off. However please note that the machine itself remains powered on so remember to shut it down to avoid power consumption.

Cleaning this machine is easy as pie. The carafe, lid and removable filter basket are all dishwasher safe and can be easily placed on the rack. To ensure these parts last longer its recommended to use a cycle, like the glassware setting to prevent any deformation of plastic components.


  • One of the advantages of this coffee machine is that it comes with a coffee filter and a measuring spoon allowing you to easily add the amount of coffee grounds.
  • Additionally the warming plate keeps your coffee at a temperature for, up to an hour before shutting off.
  • Cleaning is also made easy as all removable parts can be placed in the dishwasher.
  • Lastly, refilling the water tank is a breeze thanks to its door opening.


  • However one notable downside to consider is that this machine lacks a shutdown feature, which is usually expected at its price range.

BLACK+DECKER 5 Cup Coffeemaker

The BLACK+DECKER 5 Cup Coffeemaker is a compact coffee machine that is ideal for those with kitchen spaces like students, office workers or RV owners. Imagine having your personal caffeine dispenser neatly tucked away in your dorm room or small kitchen! It's simple operation makes brewing hassle free. Just press a button. It starts brewing.

What sets this model apart from others is its carafe design. Of the round or cylindrical shape this carafe has an elegant conical design that adds a touch of sophistication, to your kitchenware.

But its appeal goes beyond its surface—it's also incredibly practical. The handle provides a grip and the clever anti drip design ensures that pouring coffee is always a spill free experience.

This machine includes a plate to keep your coffee at the temperature, for drinking. However it's important to be mindful that the plate can become quite hot so it's best not to leave it on for long periods. Otherwise there's a chance your coffee might end up with a burnt taste.

It's worth noting that this particular model doesn't have a shutdown feature. Remember to switch off the machine when you're finished using it.


  • Comes with a 2 year warranty for added peace of mind.
  • Easy cleaning - thanks to the dishwasher removable filter basket, carafe and lid.
  • Compact design makes it ideal for smaller spaces.
  • The hot plate keeps your coffee warm until you turn off the machine.


  • The same button controls both the machine and the hot plate.
  • Leaving the plate on for long can result in a burnt taste, in your coffee.
  • Lacks an auto shutdown feature meaning you need to manually turn it off to prevent overheating.

Zojirushi EC-DAC50 Zutto 5-Cup Drip Coffeemaker

Ideal for those with limited counter space, the Zojirushi EC-DAC50 Zutto 5-Cup Drip Coffeemaker sports a sleek, compact design that will seamlessly blend into your kitchen without taking up precious real estate. This small but mighty machine is perfect for those who value convenience as well as quality.

A standout feature of this machine is its removable water reservoir. Rather than fussing with a built-in reservoir, you can easily detach this one and rinse it under tap water, a feature that simplifies your cleaning process significantly. While periodic deep cleaning with vinegar is beneficial, this design element certainly reduces the hassle.

Boosting its value, the Zojirushi coffee maker is equipped with a charcoal water filter to ensure that every cup of coffee you brew is pure and delicious. This filter purifies your water to bring out the best in your coffee, significantly enhancing the taste. You can count on approximately two years of use before it needs replacing.

However, there is a notable catch. While the warming plate, which remains active until the machine is turned off, is a boon for those who like their coffee to stay hot, it can be a source of disappointment if left unattended for too long. This is because it can alter the taste of your coffee, turning it from delightful to distasteful if it's left on for an extended period.


  • Equipped with a charcoal water filter that purifies water and enriches coffee flavor
  • Ensures your coffee remains warm until you manually switch the machine off
  • Features a removable water tank for effortless filling and cleaning
  • Offers a 1-year limited warranty that covers defects in materials and workmanship


  • Pricier when compared to other models in its category

Capresso 5 Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker

Exploring the world of mini coffee makers, we find ourselves fascinated by the Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker's functionalities. The programmability appeal of this coffee machine is a standout feature, especially for those of us who struggle to function without a caffeine kick-start in the morning. The 24-hour programmable Auto-On setting is notably convenient, allowing you to prepare the machine ahead of time and wake up to the smell of your favorite brew.

The Capresso Mini Drip Coffee Maker also offers an automatic shut-off function, which powers down the machine after two hours. This feature is a boon for those chaotic mornings when you might rush out of the house, forgetting to turn off the coffee maker.

However, as with all products, it's not all sunshine and rainbows. Despite the touted Drip-Stop feature, which theoretically allows you to sneak a cup while the machine is still brewing, it's not entirely effective. You may find yourself cleaning up an unwanted dribble of coffee on your hot plate.

Further, the 5-cup brew volume may limit your coffee consumption. At a mere 25 oz, this volume might not fill your large cup or travel mug to the brim, necessitating a quick refill once you've drained the carafe.


  • The programmability feature allows you to prepare your coffee 24 hours in advance.
  • Its compact size contributes to its appeal, especially for those with limited kitchen counter space.
  • The inclusion of a reusable gold-tone filter eliminates the need for recurrent paper filter purchases.
  • With its low power consumption, you will notice a reduction in your electricity bill.


  • The Drip-stop feature doesn't completely prevent coffee from dripping onto your hot plate when you remove the carafe.
  • The 5-cup brew volume may not yield sufficiently large servings, leading to quicker depletion of the carafe.

Buying Guide to Choosing a 5-Cup Coffee Maker

The market is overflowing with an array of 5-cup coffee makers, each with its unique set of features and capabilities. They range from user-friendly, basic models to advanced options that are adorned with an array of buttons and configurations reminiscent of an aircraft cockpit. Despite the variety, understanding the key features and characteristics can help you choose the best coffee maker that suits your needs. Here's a rundown of what to consider when navigating through the sea of 5-cup coffee makers to find your perfect brew partner.

Coffee Filter Shapes

When it comes to coffee filters they generally fall into two categories— flat bottomed and Conical filters. Conical filters are known for their shape to ensure that water is evenly distributed over the coffee grounds. On the other hand flat bottomed filters disperse the coffee grounds, over a wider surface area leading to uneven contact with water.

Does this mean that conical filters perform better than ones? Surprisingly the answer tends to be no. Conical filters often have limited space. May not be able to hold ground coffee to fill a carafe. That's why most 5 cup coffee makers come with flat bottom filters.

In today's market most coffee maker models come with filters. These filters are not environmentally friendly. Also allow some oils and micro fines to pass through resulting in a rich and full bodied brew.

However there are still some models that use paper filters. They are an affordable option but can end up being expensive in the long run especially for frequent coffee drinkers. Paper filters excel at removing debris and oils from the grounds producing a lightly flavored cup of coffee.

Carafe Types in Coffee Makers

The carafe is a critical component of any coffee maker. When choosing a carafe there are qualities to consider like; durability, ease of cleaning and a hassle free pouring experience.

Typically when it comes to carafes you have two options to choose from; glass or stainless steel. The common choice is glass because it is visually appealing and its transparency allows you to easily see how much coffee is left. Glass carafes are also affordable and easy to clean. However they don't provide the insulation properties, which means your coffee may cool down quickly.

On the other hand a stainless steel carafe, also known as a carafe is a premium option worth considering. This material offers insulation that keeps your coffee warmer for longer while keeping the cool to exterior touch. This reduces the risk of accidental burns.

Of Course every option has its drawbacks. In this case stainless steel carafes can be more challenging to clean compared to glass ones although the difference is minimal.

It's worth noting that most 5 cup coffee makers come with a glass carafe as standard. This decision is made with affordability in mind, for consumers.

Size Matters

The available counter space in your kitchen plays a critical role in determining the perfect coffee maker for you. After all, you wouldn't want to be lugging out your coffee maker from a packed cabinet each time you fancy a cup of Joe, would you?

To avoid this inconvenience, measuring the counter space before you embark on your coffee maker shopping venture is recommended. This foresight will ensure you choose a model that seamlessly fits into your kitchen layout.

An under-the-cabinet coffee maker is an innovative solution for those looking to optimize their kitchen counter space. This space-savvy choice hangs under your cabinet, cleverly freeing up room on your counter.

On the other hand, if brewing capacity is a higher priority for you, then an 8-cup coffee maker might be the right choice. This larger model can supply a steady stream of coffee for multiple servings, making it particularly useful for a household of coffee lovers or when entertaining guests.

Brewing Time

Typically, a 5-cup coffee machine takes approximately 5 to 12 minutes to prepare a full pot of freshly brewed coffee. While the variation between 5 and 12 minutes might seem insignificant to some, for those who maintain a strict "no-talkie before coffee" rule in the mornings, these minutes can feel like an eternity.

Recognizing this scenario in your morning routine means that the brewing time could be a critical factor to consider when choosing your coffee machine.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Programmable Coffee Makers

Many 5-cup coffee makers operate using a simple, one-button operation, which is relatively expected given their affordable nature. However, that doesn't imply the absence of programmable models within this price bracket. Quite the contrary, there are programmable machines available that offer the convenience of setting a timer up to 24 hours ahead. This feature allows you to wake up to a fresh cup of coffee brewed at your desired time. This convenience adds a layer of luxury to these economically priced models – transforming an otherwise mundane morning routine into a delightful experience.

Automated Functions

Some coffee machine models are equipped with incredibly useful automated functions. The auto-shutdown feature is particularly appealing as it powers off the machine automatically following a designated period of inactivity.

Furthermore, customizable settings in certain models allow you to decide the desired duration before the auto-shutdown is triggered. This feature offers peace of mind, especially when rushing out of the house in the mornings.

Another remarkable feature is the anti-drip function. This function halts the coffee flow when the carafe is removed midway through brewing. Essentially, it grants you the convenience of pouring a cup of coffee while the rest of the brew is still in progress, lending a helping hand when you're pressed for time.

Energy Efficiency

While compact, modern appliances can surprisingly add to your electricity bills, much like your oven does. Constantly leaving the appliance on for extended periods is a common mistake that many, including myself, have made.

What led me to this discovery?

My inherent habit of forgetting to turn off appliances. Fortunately, I stumbled upon appliances equipped with automatic shutdown features.

Are you concerned about power consumption for the same reasons I was?

The solution lies in opting for an appliance model with an automatic shutdown feature, ensuring you never have to fret about unnecessary energy wastage again.

The Aesthetics Factor

Let's face it: aesthetics play a significant role in our choices. No one desires an unattractive appliance taking center stage on their countertop, in full view of visitors. Most 5-cup coffee makers are crafted from plastic, steel, or a harmonious blend of these two materials.

Upon diving into the vast selection of coffee makers, I was struck by the sheer variety of designs that these two materials could emulate. From sleek modernity, nostalgic retro, and bare-minimum minimalism to even a playful Barbie pink - there's a design for every taste out there. Whatever your personal style may be, rest assured there exists a model on the market that effortlessly aligns with your aesthetic preferences.

The Final Verdict

It's no secret that the market is flooded with an array of impressive 5-cup coffee makers, so settling on a single choice can be daunting. Topping this list is the AMASTE Drip Coffee Maker, a gem characterized by its unique features. This versatile machine allows you to modify your coffee's potency to your liking and offers a choice between four different colors. Its retro-chic design makes it an attractive addition to any kitchen. An added bonus is its low noise level and automatic shut-off feature after 30 minutes, ensuring both a peaceful environment and energy conservation.

However, if the vintage aesthetic doesn't resonate with your taste, fear not. This list comprises other excellent models that are definitely worth considering. No matter which you opt for, rest assured that satisfaction will be at the end of your brewing experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the importance of considering counter space when buying a coffee maker?

Taking into account the dimensions of your kitchen counter space while selecting a coffee maker helps prevent the hassle of moving it around. It ensures that the machine seamlessly blends into your kitchen setup enhancing both its appearance and functionality.

Why might someone consider an under-the-cabinet coffee maker?

An under the cabinet coffee maker is a choice for individuals who want to maximize their kitchen counter space. By hanging beneath a cabinet it frees up room on the countertop.

How long does a 5-cup coffee machine take to brew a full pot of coffee?

Typically a 5 cup coffee machine takes between 5 to 12 minutes to prepare a pot of freshly brewed coffee. The brewing time holds significance for those who prefer their morning cup of joe upon waking up.

What is the advantage of programmable coffee makers?

Programmable coffee makers provide added convenience by allowing you to set a timer, up to 24 hours in advance. This feature enables you to wake up to the aroma and taste of brewed java at your desired time adding an extra touch of luxury to your morning routine.

What are some useful automated features in coffee machines?

Coffee machines offer a range of automated features that enhance convenience. For instance the auto shutdown feature automatically turns off the machine after a period of inactivity. Additionally there's the drip function that halts the coffee flow when you remove the carafe during brewing.

How can a coffee maker contribute to energy efficiency?

Using a coffee maker with an automatic shutdown feature can help promote energy efficiency. This feature ensures that the appliance powers off after a time preventing power consumption.

How does the aesthetics factor influence the choice of a coffee maker?

When choosing a coffee maker aesthetics play a role. The design and material used in constructing the coffee maker greatly impact its appeal. With various designs and materials available. From plastic, to steel. You can select a model that matches your style and complements your kitchen décor.

Check out Lifeboost Coffee Medium Roast.

Drop a Comment

All comments are moderated before being published